ShortlistFox
← Back to results

Level 2 Claims Manager

amwins

1580 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 310 Sunrise, Florida 33323; 6201 West Plano Parkway Suite 2… View full location
  • 1580 Sawgrass Corporate Parkway Suite 310 Sunrise, Florida 33323; 6201 West Plano Parkway Suite 225 Plano, Texas 75093
Apply

About the role

We are seeking an experienced, results-driven Level 2 Claims Manager (Bodily Injury) to lead a team of BI claims professionals responsible for coverage analysis, liability assessment, negotiation and resolution of both represented and unrepresented claims on non-standard auto policies. This leader will oversee day-to-day operations, drive sound indemnity and expense outcomes, and develop the adjusters on the team.

The Level 2 Claims Manager supervises a team of BI claim representatives and is accountable for coverage and liability decisions, reserve and settlement quality, and regulatory compliance and team performance. The manager works closely with Level 1 managers, injury and material damage teams, SIU, subrogation, defense counsel and company leadership.

Along with competitive salary, Amwins Specialty Auto offers a full range of benefits including insurance, retirement, and educational reimbursement programs. Amwins Specialty Auto is part of Amwins Group, the largest specialty broker in the United States, with over $14 billion of premium.

This is an in-office position in either Plano, TX or Sunrise, FL with the option for a hybrid schedule once training is complete. 

Responsibilities:

  • Lead a team of adjusters handling represented and unrepresented bodily injury claims.
  • Own coverage and liability decisions: review policy language, endorsements and exclusions, and issue reservation of rights and coverage position letters as needed.
  • Review adjuster liability, comparative fault and damages evaluations for accuracy and support; confirm decisions are well documented.
  • Direct negotiation strategy on represented claims, including policy-limit and time-limited demands. Identify excess and bad-faith exposure early and escalate.
  • Ensure prompt, fair handling of unrepresented claimants, including timely contact, clear communication and appropriate release practices.
  • Grant and monitor settlement authority within assigned limits; escalate requests that exceed it.
  • Manage reserves for adequacy and timeliness throughout the life of each claim.
  • Identify and escalate suspected fraud, subrogation and recovery opportunities, and complex or high-severity claims.
  • Ensure compliance with company standards and state requirements, including claim handling timelines, Medicare reporting and regulatory complaints.
  • Hire, coach and develop adjusters; conduct file audits, one-on-ones and performance reviews.
  • Track and report team results, including indemnity and expense trends, cycle time, closing ratios, reserve accuracy, and quality scores.
  • Handle escalated insured, claimant, attorney and agent concerns with clear explanations of decisions.
  • Foster a high-performing team culture focused on service excellence and continuous improvement.

Qualifications:

  • 5–7 years of bodily injury claims experience, including coverage analysis and liability evaluation; non-standard auto preferred.
  • 2+ years of claims supervisory or lead experience preferred.
  • Proven experience negotiating and resolving represented BI claims.
  • Working knowledge of TX, OK and FL claim handling laws, including time-limit demand and extra-contractual exposure.
  • Must hold or be able to obtain a Florida and Texas adjuster license prior to start date; other state licenses as required.
  • Bachelor’s degree or above preferred.
  • Strong judgment in guiding team members through complex, high-severity or sensitive claims.
  • Excellent communication, coaching and leadership skills.
  • Strong organizational and time-management skills.
  • Detail-oriented with a commitment to accuracy and regulatory compliance.

The Amwins Advantage: Benefits & Perks Available to Full-Time US Based Employees

  • Medical, Dental, Vision available your first day of employment
    • Choice of medical plans through Blue Cross Blue Shield; Kaiser available for CA employees
  • Mental health support including:
    • Virtual therapy
    • Digital coaching
    • 24/7 EAP counseling
  • Company-paid Basic Life & AD&D Insurance, Short-Term Disability, and Employee Assistance Program
  • Health Savings Account with company contributions 
  • Health Care FSA, Dependent Care FSA, and Commuter Benefits
  • Parental Leave and Adoption Assistance
  • Voluntary coverage options:
    • Life Insurance
    • Critical Illness
    • Accident
    • Identity Theft Protection
  • Retiree medical benefits available for Medicare-eligible retirees
  • 401(k) with company match
  • Generous Paid Time Off and Company Holiday Schedule
  • Collaborative, continuing education focused work environment
  • Career advancement opportunities